Deep Sea Mining: Balancing Resource Extraction and Ocean Conservation

A revelation from May 2023 about the diversity thriving in the profound depths of the Pacific Ocean, where even sunlight struggles to penetrate, has amazed everyone. More than 5,000 new species have been discovered on the seabed in the Pacific Ocean. This area has also been identified as a future hotspot for deep sea mining. This juncture has raised questions about balancing human ambition and preserving our oceanic frontiers. Whether it is possible to harvest the bounty of the deep sea while safeguarding its fragile wonders? Keep reading as we explore the possibility of balancing resource extraction with ocean conservation. Starting with – What is deep sea mining?

What is Deep Sea Mining?

On the ocean bed, thousands of meters below the surface, lies mineral deposits. These mineral deposits include metals like cobalt, manganese, nickel, silver, gold, copper, and more. Gigantic machines are used to scoop deposits of these minerals from the ocean floor. Deep sea mining refers to the practice of removing these metals and minerals from the ocean’s seabed. 

Mining ocean resources remains a controversial topic because of its potential environmental impact. These concerns have fueled debates and ignited strong opposition from environmental groups, scientists, and governments around the world. Consequently, international regulations and agreements are still under development, aiming to establish responsible practices and minimize the environmental impact of deep sea mining. But even with so much opposition, why is everyone allured towards mining the ocean bed?

Source | How deep sea mining works? 

Why the Allure of Deep Sea Mining?

The allure stems from the economic benefits of deep sea mining, which propel us to continue this controversial practice. Let’s look at some of the benefits of deep sea mining:

• Critical resources for clean energy technologies: One of the primary arguments favoring the mining of ocean beds is its potential to provide access to minerals required for the green energy revolution. Such minerals are called ‘critical minerals,’ and include cobalt, nickel, rare earth elements, and other precious metals. They form essential components for batteries, wind turbines, and other green technologies vital for transitioning to a low-carbon future.
• Economic growth: Deep sea mining can create new jobs and boost economic growth, particularly in developing countries with access to deep-sea mineral resources.
• Scientific discovery: Deep sea exploration is still in its early stages, and much remains unknown about the unique ecosystem of ocean floors. Mining the ocean floor could inadvertently lead to the discovery of new species, previously unknown biological processes, and valuable scientific insights about the deep ocean.

Source | Example of manganese nodule, found on the sea bed

Environmental Impacts of Deep Sea Mining

Despite the potential benefits of deep sea mining, the process has significant environmental concerns, including: 

• Habitat destruction: One of the major cons of deep sea mining is habitat destruction. Mining activities directly damage the ocean bed, disturbing sensitive ocean habitats. It destroys numerous deep-sea creatures’ homes and vital feeding grounds, potentially leading to species loss and ecosystem collapse.
• Deep sea mining pollution: Deep sea mining pollution includes noise and light pollution from the mining equipment. The equipment disrupts communication, navigation, and breeding behaviors in organisms that are adapted to a quiet, dark environment.
• Sediment and plume disturbance: The extraction process generates plumes of fine sediment that can smother nearby life forms, particularly filter feeders like corals and sponges. These plumes disperse beyond the immediate mining site, affecting the entire ecosystem. They reduce visibility and hinder the mobility of marine organisms, similar to what air pollution does for humans on land.
• Chemical threats: Mining releases toxic compounds, metals, chemicals, and radioactive elements trapped in the seafloor sediments, contaminating the water column and harming marine life. These pollutants bioaccumulate in the food chain, posing long-term risks not only to the ocean ecosystem but also to humans.

Balancing Resource Extraction and Ocean Conservation

Despite having potential benefits, the negative environmental impacts of deep sea mining raise significant concerns. Balancing resource extraction and ocean conservation thus becomes paramount to addressing environmental concerns and ensuring a sustainable future. Here is how it can be done: 

• Strict regulations and enforcement: Robust regulations and effective enforcement mechanisms are essential to address the environmental impacts of deep sea mining. The regulations may include limits on extraction quantities, establishing protected areas, and environmental impact assessments. Organizations like the International Seabed Authority (ISA) must continue to draw regulations for protecting and preserving the marine environment.

Source | International Seabed Authority (ISA) entrusted to protect deep seas. 

• Technological advancements: Advanced technologies must be developed to minimize the negative environmental impacts of deep sea mining. These technologies must promote cleaner extraction methods, minimize sediment plumes, and reduce noise pollution.
• Investing in research: More research and innovation is required to improve our understanding of the deep sea and its ecosystems. The focus should be on studying deep-sea biodiversity, ecosystem functions, and the long-term consequences of mining activities. This knowledge would help develop effective conservation strategies and ensure responsible deep sea mining practices.
• Sustainable practices: Mining companies must adopt sustainable practices that prioritize environmental protection. Mining operators should incorporate sediment control systems and waste management strategies.
• Global collaboration: International cooperation and collaboration are essential for effective regulation and governance of deep sea mining. These include sharing best practices, fostering transparency, and ensuring equitable access to the benefits of deep sea mining while protecting the deep sea.
• Alternative sources: Beyond deep sea mining, a recycling revolution can answer the quest for critical minerals. By finding ways to reuse existing materials, such as battery metals, the problem of the need for more resources can be tackled. A responsible land-based exploration with stricter regulations can also offer a path to energy resources without sacrificing the ocean’s wonders.

The efforts towards balancing resource extraction and ocean conservation in deep sea mining are already in play. Norway’s government has opened parts of its seabed to mining and has assured it would impose strict environmental safeguards to minimize the cons of deep sea mining.

Sustainable Future for Deep Sea Mining

Deep sea mining presents both opportunities and risks. Striking a balance between resource extraction and ocean conservation requires a science-based approach, strict regulations, responsible practices, and global cooperation. By prioritizing environmental protection and investing in research and technology, we can ensure that deep sea mining contributes to a sustainable future for both humanity and the deep sea’s delicate ecosystems.

Check out Entropy for more such captivating insights and the latest updates. Embark on a scientific voyage towards exploration of knowledge and discovery with us!